Willow Creek Estate

Two quotes said tear it off. The slate was sound; the nails and the flashing were not, and those are cheaper to replace.

Roofer laying tiles on a pitched roof
  • 3,500
    Square feet
  • 15
    Days on site
  • <200
    Slates replaced
  • 1919
    Year the roof was laid

The challenge

The house was built in 1919 and still wore its original slate. Two contractors had quoted a full tear-off and a synthetic replacement, on the reasonable-sounding logic that a hundred-year-old roof has done its hundred years. But slate does not really wear out — the nails holding it up do, and so does the flashing around everything it meets. The owners wanted to know whether they were being sold a roof they did not need, and they were right to ask.

What we did

We surveyed the roof tile by tile and sounded each one, which is slow work and the only honest way to answer the question. Fewer than two hundred slates were genuinely broken or delaminated out of several thousand; the rest were fine and would outlive everyone involved. What had failed was the fixings and the metalwork. So we relaid rather than replaced: salvaged slate reused wherever it was sound, reclaimed matching stock brought in for the gaps, copper nails throughout, and every valley, chimney and abutment rebuilt in new lead. The scaffold stayed up for three weeks because none of this can be rushed without breaking the material you are trying to save.

The result

Fifteen working days on the roof, a fraction of the replacement quotes, and a house that still looks like itself from the street. The owners have a documented survey of every slope, which their insurer accepted without argument.

“Two companies told us the roof was finished. The third one climbed up and checked.”

(More projects)

See recommended projects

Cedar Ridge Residence

Full replacement after a hidden fifteen-year leak had quietly destroyed a third of the deck.

Roof size
2,850 sq ft
Duration
3 days
Residential
View Project

Harborview Apartments

A flat roof over forty occupied units, replaced without a single tenant complaint filed.

Roof size
3,050 sq ft
Duration
5 days
Commercial
View Project

Maple Grove Colonial

A denied hail claim, reopened with photographic evidence and approved at full replacement value.

Roof size
3,210 sq ft
Duration
7 days
Insurance
View Project
(Free estimate)

Let’s get up there and have a look

Free inspection, a photographed report, and a fixed quote inside twenty-four hours. No pressure, no call-backs from a sales team.